Dog or Cat? The Best Pet For Your Busy Lifestyle

Dog-Cat 1a

Cat Or Dog – Which Pet Is Right For You?

Pets bring ingredients to your home that nothing else can bring: love, companionship, a furry friend to warm your feet at night, and someone to come home to at the end of the day that is always happy to see you.

The American Veterinary Medical Association’s most recent study found that nearly 57 percent of American households have a pet, and of those pets, dogs are the most popular, followed by cats. About 38 percent of households were home to one or more dogs in 2016, and 25 percent had at least one resident feline.

They’re both popular picks for a four-legged companion, but which one is right for you? Picking the right pet for the way you live, particularly if you’re busy, is important so that both you and the animal will be happy.

Let’s take a look at some of the questions to ask yourself when making a decision.

Is A Cat The Perfect Pet For You?

All You Need Is Cat

How long are you away from home? Long work days away from home can be hard on a pet, but in general a cat will handle it better than a dog. There are a few reasons for that.

First of all, there’s the need to go outside. While a cat can have free access to a litter box during the day, dogs need to be let out. You can mitigate this problem if you’re able to provide a dog door to a secure outdoor area, use a doggy daycare, or find someone to come by and let the dog out.

All of those require a little more effort and cost than simply leaving a litter box, making the cat the clear winner for convenience.

Lounging Cat

Second, there’s the issue of loneliness. Cats tend to be more independent than dogs, which means they handle being alone better. Dogs can suffer from separation anxiety especially if they are rescue animals. Recent research indicates that dogs have stronger feelings of love for their humans, which means they’re going to be unhappy being away from you for too long.

Hunger can be another issue. Cats can generally free-feed better than dogs as they aren’t as prone to over-eating. Dogs, on the other hand, are likely to gobble up any food left for them and then become hungry again long before they hear you at the door.

Remember that when left home alone, a bored animal can get into trouble. Cats can cause their share of problems, but bored dogs have a greater tendency to destroy things. They may also bark a lot, disturbing your neighbors.

Can Your Dog Come Along?

Happi Corgi

A dog can fit into a busy lifestyle better if you let him or her come along – just make sure your four-legged travel buddies are covered by insurance. For example, if you’re watching your kids’ play soccer or baseball outdoors, your pup might be welcome to cheer from the sidelines with you.

You might be surprised at the places that will let your dog join you. In addition to the obvious (pet stores), several stores allow pets to come inside, including surprising ones like Macy’s and The Apple Store.

Many restaurants will also allow your dog to join you for a meal on the patio and may even bring out some water and a treat. Bear in mind that your dog will need to be very well-behaved to be welcome, so a little extra time in obedience school might be a good plan.

Pretty Kitty

If a lot of your off-work time is spent in places where a dog isn’t welcome, you may need to lean towards a cat instead. Doubling up a long day away at work with many evenings out of the house will likely prove to be just too much alone time for a dog.

And remember that it’s never a good idea to leave a dog in a car, even if you don’t think it’s that hot outside. So, if you can’t bring the dog in with you it’s best to leave your pet at home.

How Much Time Do You Have To Meet A Pet’s Needs?

2 Outdoor Active Shepherds

Dogs need exercise, which generally means taking them for regular walks. It’s important to their health, both physical and mental, and it’s great bonding time with you.

While all dogs should get some time on the leash, if you’re too busy to fit in daily walks, you might want to consider a lower energy breed that doesn’t need quite as much exercise. You could also consider adopting an older dog; senior dogs don’t need to burn as much energy as a puppy.

Of course, if part of your busy lifestyle includes a daily morning run, a high energy dog to join you might be a great choice.

In addition to walking a dog, there are regular trips to the groomer to be considered. If you don’t want to worry about grooming, consider a low-maintenance breed like a beagle, whose short coat requires little attention.

If regular walks are simply out of the question for your lifestyle, however, you might be a cat person. Cats don’t need to be walked and can be kept entertained indoors with toys, cat trees, scratching posts, and the company of another cat.

Do You Travel Frequently?

Girl With Kittens

If you travel a lot, a cat might be a better choice. Their independence makes it easier for them to handle being left home (with regular visits from a pet sitter to clean the litter and provide fresh food and water, of course). Or, should you choose to board your cat, the per-day cost is considerably less than for dogs.

Dogs can, of course, be boarded or cared for by a pet sitter. It’s worth remembering what we mentioned above, though, about how much dogs bond with their people. If you’re gone a lot, a dog is going to miss you.

What Do You Want From A Pet?

Dog-Cat 2

One of the biggest questions to ask yourself when deciding which pet is best for you is what you want from your new furry friend.

Both cats and dogs provide companionship, but a dog is more social and generally offers a lot more affection than most cats (it’s not a hard and fast rule, and some cats are very affectionate). If you’re looking for a best friend that wants to be by your side all the time, someone to share adventures and exploring the great outdoors, you might be a dog person.

If you want a pet that will curl up next to you on the couch for a good Netflix binge but also be independent when you’re off handling your busy schedule, a cat is probably the way to go.

Black Cat by Keyboard

Remember that your pet needs something from you, too. It’s important to give a lot of thought to what you can provide for a pet before you bring one home. The ASPCA estimates that 6.5 million animals enter shelters each year, and some of those are given up by owners that weren’t able to care for them.

On the flip side of that, there are millions of dogs and cats in those shelters looking for a home. If you’re ready to make room in your life for one of them you will have a loyal friend for life.

Copyright © 2019 by Create With Joy. All Rights Reserved.
If you see this content posted elsewhere, please contact the site owner.
Thank you for helping to prevent content theft!

24 Responses to “Dog or Cat? The Best Pet For Your Busy Lifestyle”

Read below or add a comment...

  1. Teresa
    Twitter: thenanahood

    I wish I could have cats but the hubs is allergic. We have lots of pups though!

  2. Brian Frum says:

    Hmmmm, we of five cats used to live with 2 dogs so we say get both!

  3. I have always been a dog person. I guess I need their affection as much as they need mine. I love animals in general, but a dog (currently a cocker spaniel) has always been my pet of choice. Of course being retired, I can spend all of the time necessary to keep our Lucy happy. Have a blessed day.

  4. I have allergies to one so that one is easy!

  5. Amy Johnson says:

    We have a cat, although we love dogs too. Cats are just so much easier to care for because we travel and are away from a lot.

  6. This is a thorough review which someone considering a pet will find useful. My family has had both dogs and cats but have no pets now. Recently, we entertained a friend’s cat while he was out of town. We thoroughly enjoyed it. This kitty was smart and affectionate and definitely stole my heart. I was sad when she went home. If I do get another pet, it will likely be a cat.

  7. Karen says:

    I am more of a cat person, basically because they are so much easier to take care of and I admire their softness and agility. My husband is more of a dog person because he loves to walk and appreciates the companionship of a dog.

  8. Michelle says:

    You make excellent points about the pros and cons of both types of critters. I was a cat person all my life. There self-sufficiency made them an easier pet to have, especially when working. Then I met my husband who is deathly allergic to cats. Now that we are both retired, so we have a cat-sized dog who goes almost every where with us.

  9. I have cutey puppy & I just love him madly but I like cat’s also. Lovely article. So special. Thanks a lot for sharing.

  10. Fun! We love old Tuck, our big, lazy St. Bernard! He’s a great part of our family!

  11. Allyson says:

    Great info on dogs versus cats. We have a huge orange tabby and an outside feral kitty. They are both so much part of our family.

  12. LaFayne says:

    Great article. I prefer dogs more than cats, even though I have a cat as my pet. I don’t know why but I do… I can’t say this out loud for to hear me…🤤

    • Create With Joy
      Twitter: CreateWithJoy1

      I’m a cat person at heart but I love them both.
      I wish I were in a position to add some dogs to our family!
      (PS Thanks for sharing – your secret is safe with me!)

  13. We are definitely cat people. Many of the reasons you listed apply to us but we genuinely love cats. We were catless for a few years because several of our grandchildren had serious allergies but since they are grown and many of them out of town, we found a sweet rescue cat. We had forgotten what a joy they can be even when they are mischievous!

    • Create With Joy
      Twitter: CreateWithJoy1

      I am SO glad to hear that you have a sweet cat again Donna.
      Every cat lover should have at least one feline companion to love and be loved by! 🙂

  14. Susan Sikes says:

    I can’t imagine life without a dog. I guess I have always had one. I do like that you caution people before jumping into pet ownership though. It is heartbreaking to see all of those in the shelters.

    • Create With Joy
      Twitter: CreateWithJoy1

      I can’t imagine life without either a cat or dog either Susan! I am down to one cat and the house feels so empty without more!
      I am hoping we can grow our four-legged family once more in the future!


  1. […] friendly) (These features were chosen from the June “You’re the STAR” blog hop)Dog or Cat? The Best Pet for Your Busy Lifestyle by Create With Joy Help For the Grief-Stricken by Dr. Michelle Bengsten Frugal Camping Hacks Using Dollar Tree […]

Thanks for visiting Create With Joy! Your comments are greatly appreciated!


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.